Choose a remote access VPN by criteria
The best remote access VPN is the one that fits your apps, your devices, and your team. This guide gives you ten criteria and three product categories, not a ranked list. Firezone publishes this guide, and Firezone is one of the options.
The user proves who they are
A good product sends the sign-in to your identity provider. It keeps no second list of passwords.
A policy makes the decision
The policy engine reads the group, the device, and the conditions. It permits one app, not a network.
A tunnel carries the traffic
The client encrypts the traffic and sends it to a gateway that sits near the app.
All other traffic stops
The gateway refuses each connection that no rule permits. This default is the largest difference between products.
Start with what your people must reach
Each list of the best remote access VPN products ranks vendors. A ranked list cannot know your network. This guide gives you the questions to ask, and you can use them on any product.
Three categories of product do remote access for a business:
- Legacy VPN. A VPN server or appliance at the edge of the network accepts connections from the internet. A connected device becomes part of the network.
- Mesh VPN. Each device runs an agent, and the devices connect directly to each other. A coordination service gives out the keys.
- Zero trust network access (ZTNA). A policy permits one user to reach one app. All other access is refused by default.
Before you compare products, write three lists: the apps people must reach, the devices they use, and the rules you must enforce. The lists tell you which category fits. The criteria below help you compare products in that category.
Criteria for access control and identity
1. Access control granularity
Ask what the smallest unit of access is. A legacy VPN usually gives access to a subnet. A better product gives access to one host, one DNS name, or one port. Small units limit the damage when an attacker steals a credential.
2. Identity provider integration
The product must use your identity provider for sign-in, through OpenID Connect or SAML. Your multi-factor rules then apply to remote access with no extra work. Ask also about directory sync. When you suspend a user in the directory, the product must remove access quickly and automatically.
3. Device checks
A correct password on an infected laptop is still a risk. Ask if the product can check the device before it permits access. Common checks are disk encryption, the operating system version, and a certificate that proves the company manages the device.
4. Logging
You need a record of who connected to what, and when. Ask if the product logs each connection or only each sign-in. Ask how long it keeps the logs, and if it can send them to your SIEM.
Criteria for the protocol, the deployment, and reliability
5. Protocol and speed
The protocol sets the upper limit of speed. WireGuard is a modern protocol with a small code base, and it runs over UDP. IPsec is mature and is built into most operating systems. A VPN that runs TLS over TCP passes through most firewalls, but it is slower when the network loses packets.
The route matters as much as the protocol. A product that sends each packet through one central site adds delay for each remote user. Ask if traffic goes directly from the device to the network that has the app.
6. How it deploys
Ask if the product needs an open inbound port on your firewall. A VPN server that listens on the internet is a target, and you must patch it quickly. Some products make only outbound connections, so there is no listener to attack.
7. Reliability
One VPN server is one point of failure. Ask how the product fails over, how long failover takes, and what occurs if the vendor's service is offline.
Criteria for clients, price, and source code
8. Clients for each platform
Make a list of each operating system in your company, and include phones and servers. Check that a maintained client exists for each one. Ask about a headless client for servers and CI jobs, and about deployment through your MDM.
9. Price model
Most products for a business VPN charge for each user for each month. Some charge for each device, for each gateway, or for bandwidth. Check which features are in which plan. Single sign-on, device checks, and log export are frequently in the higher plans.
10. Open source
Remote access software sees your most sensitive traffic. With open source code, you and independent researchers can read how the product works. Ask which parts are open: the client, the gateway, the control plane, or all of them.
No product is best on all ten criteria. Select the three criteria that matter most to your company, and give them the most weight.
Find the category that fits
Answer these questions to find the category of remote access VPN for business that fits your needs. One of the results tells you that Firezone is not the best fit.
How Firezone does on these criteria
Firezone is an open source zero trust network access platform built on WireGuard. You run the Gateways, and Firezone runs the control plane. These are the facts for each criterion.
- Granularity. A Resource is a DNS name, an IP address, or a CIDR range. You can limit a Resource to specified ports. A Policy gives one Group access to one Resource.
- Identity. People sign in with any OIDC provider or an email code. Directory sync is in the Business plan.
- Device checks. Device posture and device trust use records from your MDM and EDR tools.
- Logging. All plans include audit logs for changes, sessions, API requests, and flows.
- Deployment. Clients and Gateways make only outbound connections. You open no inbound firewall ports.
- Reliability. Put two or more Gateways in a Site. The Client moves to a healthy Gateway when one fails.
- Clients. Clients exist for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, and ChromeOS, with headless Clients for Linux and Windows.
- Price and source. The Starter plan is free. See the pricing page for the paid plans. The source code is public.
Where Firezone is not the best fit
Firezone has no clientless browser access and no session recording. It uses UDP, and it has no fallback mode that runs over TCP port 443. If one of these is a hard requirement, select a different category of tool.
Legacy VPN, mesh VPN, and Firezone on the criteria
The table shows the usual design of the two older categories next to Firezone. Use it to prepare questions for each vendor.
| Legacy VPN | Mesh VPN | Firezone | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smallest unit of access | A subnet | A device, sometimes a port | One name, address, or port range |
| No inbound firewall ports | NoThe VPN server listens on the internet | Yes | Yes |
| Sign-in with your identity provider | PartialDepends on the product | Yes | YesAny OIDC provider |
| Reaches systems that run no agent | Yes | PartialThrough a subnet router | YesThrough a Gateway |
| Device-to-device access | No | Yes | YesDevice Pools |
| Clientless browser access | PartialSome have a web portal | No | No |
| Open source | PartialSome products | PartialOften the client only | Yes |
The table describes the usual design of each category. A specific product can be different. Read the documentation of the product before you decide.
Common questions
What is the best remote access VPN for a small business?
The answer depends on what people must reach. A small team that reaches a few servers does well with a ZTNA product or a mesh VPN. The two categories need no VPN appliance. Use the ten criteria in this guide to compare the products in the category that fits.
Is a business VPN different from a consumer VPN?
Yes. A consumer VPN hides your IP address from websites. A business VPN connects your people to private company systems. The two products solve different problems, and a consumer VPN gives no access to a private network.
Is zero trust network access a type of VPN?
ZTNA does the same work as a remote access VPN, and many ZTNA products use a VPN protocol such as WireGuard. The difference is the access model. A VPN connects a device to a network. ZTNA connects a user to one app, after it checks a policy.
Is WireGuard faster than IPsec or a TLS VPN?
WireGuard is usually fast because the protocol is simple and runs over UDP. Results depend on the hardware, the network, and the route. Test each product on your own network before you decide.
Can I run a new product next to the VPN that I have now?
Usually, yes. Firezone runs beside an existing VPN, and you can move one app at a time. Ask each vendor if its client can coexist with your current VPN client.